Supreme Court Declines Custodia Bank’s Fed Master Account Appeal
The U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear Custodia Bank's appeal regarding its rejected Federal Reserve master account, leaving a lower court ruling intact that allows regional Federal Reserve Banks to deny access to eligible applicants.
On November 16, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear Custodia Bank’s appeal in case No. 26-62, leaving in place a 2–1 appellate ruling that allows regional Federal Reserve Banks to deny master accounts even to legally eligible applicants.
This decision concludes Custodia’s current petitioning effort to force direct access to the Federal Reserve’s payment network. The Wyoming bank’s state charter is still not enough to secure that access, maintaining an obstacle for crypto-centric financial institutions aiming to transfer dollars without relying on a correspondent bank.
Supreme Court Leaves Custodia Bank’s Account Denial in Place
What Happened on November 16?
The Court opted not to take up Custodia’s challenge against the Federal Reserve’s refusal to issue it a master account. The docket listing for Custodia Bank, Inc. v. Federal Reserve Board of Governors appeared under “certiorari denied” on the Monday order list.
Related: Rain Pushes Into U.S. Banking With Stablecoin Trust Charter as OCC Faces Legal Challenge
Because of this procedural outcome, the lower-court judgment remains intact. The foundational legal reasoning for Custodia’s dispute continues to be the Tenth Circuit’s interpretation of federal banking law, rather than a fresh Supreme Court ruling on the merits.
Which Decision Survives?
The Tenth Circuit issued a ruling on October 31, 2025, that upheld the Kansas City Fed’s discretion to turn down the application. The majority concluded that fulfilling the legal criteria to apply does not grant a bank an enforceable entitlement to an account.
Custodia had petitioned the Supreme Court to evaluate whether regional Reserve Bank presidents possess the authority to deny master accounts to legally eligible nonmember banks. Both the Board of Governors and the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City contested the review.
Custodia’s Wyoming Charter Meets Separate Federal Decisions
What Kind of Bank Is Custodia?
Custodia operates as a Wyoming special purpose depository institution headed by chief executive Caitlin Long. Its charter forbids lending and mandates that dollar deposits be backed entirely by liquid assets in full reserve.
These stipulations form the foundation of the bank’s proposed alternative to traditional banking. Custodia has maintained that its business model can support emerging industries and offer safeguards against bank runs, as noted in previous coverage of its appeal.
Which Federal Reserve Bodies Rejected Its Requests?
While the Kansas City Fed processed the application for a master account, the Board of Governors handled Custodia’s separate application for Federal Reserve membership. Both requests were turned down on January 27, 2023.
These actions addressed two distinct petitions: an account at a regional Reserve Bank and membership within the Federal Reserve System. The Supreme Court petition focused specifically on the authority to refuse account access to an otherwise qualified nonmember institution.
This distinction is vital to the legal argument. Because Custodia’s challenge hinged on statutory language regarding access for nonmember banks, the disagreement expanded past the question of whether the Board ought to approve its membership application.
Custodia’s Application Began in October 2020
How Did an Account Application Become a Lawsuit?
Custodia filed its master account application with the Kansas City Fed in October 2020. Although the Reserve Bank verified its legal eligibility in January 2021, the application sat pending.
Custodia filed a lawsuit against the Board of Governors and the Kansas City Fed in June 2022 due to the prolonged delay. The litigation initially aimed to secure a decision; however, the subsequent account denial thrust the Reserve Bank’s refusal power to the forefront of the case.
How Did the Review Framework Change?
While Custodia’s applications were under review in August 2022, the Board released guidelines for evaluating master-account requests. Institutions lacking federal deposit insurance or oversight by a federal banking regulator were placed into Tier 3.
Custodia fell into this tier, which the guidelines indicated would generally be subjected to the most rigorous evaluation. Consequently, its Wyoming charter and legal qualifications left it subject to a demanding federal review of its operating model.
What Reasons Did the Fed Give for Rejection?
The Kansas City Fed characterized Custodia’s business model as “unprecedented” and “narrowly focused on crypto-asset activities.” It determined that the associated risks carried a high probability of conflicting with safe and sound banking principles.
In a separate decision, the Board stated that approving membership would breach standards concerning financial, managerial, and corporate powers factors. These represented the Fed’s formal evaluations of the applications, while Custodia continued defending the merits of its banking framework.
On March 29, 2024, U.S. District Judge Scott W. Skavdahl ruled against Custodia, determining that Reserve Banks maintain discretion over master accounts and issuing summary judgment for the Kansas City Fed. The Tenth Circuit subsequently affirmed the decision, and the full appeals court declined a rehearing on March 13, 2026.
The Custodia Ruling Turns on “May” and “Shall”
Why Did the Majority Find That Account Access Is Discretionary?
Judge David Ebel, joined by Judge Veronica Rossman, interpreted Section 342 of the Federal Reserve Act as bestowing discretion. The text states that a Reserve Bank “may receive” deposits—phrasing the majority viewed as granting permission to accept them rather than imposing a mandate.
The bank countered with an argument based on the Monetary Control Act of 1980, which dictates that Federal Reserve services “shall be available” to nonmember banks. The majority viewed this mandate as a pricing directive rather than an absolute entitlement to a master account.
This reading creates a clear boundary between eligibility and approval. An institution can meet the criteria to request Federal Reserve services while a regional Reserve Bank preserves its authority to deny the account required for direct access.
Why Did the Dissent Disagree?
Judge Timothy Tymkovich viewed the 1980 legislation as a mandate requiring access to Federal Reserve payment services for all nonmember depository institutions. He rejected the restrictive interpretation of the statute’s mandatory language put forward by the majority.
“We are bound by the ordinary language of the statute and, in my view, shall means shall,” he noted in his dissenting opinion. His stance would have enforced different practical implications of the availability requirement for qualified applicants like Custodia.
The core disagreement centered on the obligations established by federal law. The majority’s perspective ultimately prevailed, allowing the Kansas City Fed’s rejection to stand despite Custodia’s statutory eligibility.
A 2–1 Split Leaves Limited Recourse for Rejected Applicants
What Does the Appellate Division Mean for Custodia?
Judges Ebel and Rossman comprised the appellate majority, with Judge Tymkovich voicing the dissent. This 2–1 split defined the Tenth Circuit’s verdict on account access.
Following its defeat at the appellate level, Custodia sought further review by requesting a rehearing and later submitting a petition to the Supreme Court in July 2026. The November denial leaves the ruling handed down by the appellate majority untouched.
This legal journey spans from an application filed in 2020 to a Supreme Court order delivered in 2026. The lawsuit itself commenced in 2022 after Custodia had already waited for action from the Kansas City Fed.
How Far Does the Surviving Ruling Reach?
The practical fallout of this decision is especially pronounced within the Tenth Circuit. As Bitcoin Magazine noted regarding the outcome, rejected crypto-focused banks and other novel charters face narrow judicial options in that jurisdiction when a Reserve Bank cuts off access.
The surviving judgment stands as appellate precedent. Because the Supreme Court declined to review the case, that ruling remains in effect without an accompanying merits opinion endorsing the majority’s statutory rationale.
For any other state-chartered applicant, the line separating eligibility from entitlement remains critical. Acquiring a charter can establish the grounds to apply, yet leave the final federal account determination uncertain.
Custodia’s Dispute Preserves a Banking-Access Barrier
What Changes for Direct Payment Access?
A master account would grant Custodia unmediated access to Fedwire and other Federal Reserve payment channels. Without one, a state-chartered bank is forced to route money movements through a correspondent institution.
Custodia argued that this reliance on intermediaries handicaps the competitiveness of digital-asset banks even when they operate under state regulation. Its application aimed to remove that dependency by integrating the bank directly into the Federal Reserve’s payment network.
The account denial keeps that hurdle firmly in place. For crypto-focused banking operations, the verdict dictates their pathway into dollar payments and the third-party institutions they must depend upon.
Where Do the Bank’s Position and the Fed’s Concerns Diverge?
Custodia emphasized its charter, which outlaws lending and mandates liquid asset backing for dollar deposits. Conversely, the Kansas City Fed concentrated on the perceived risks tied to a business model centered heavily on crypto-asset operations.
The court battle brought the legitimacy of the account-granting authority into question. Under the standing interpretation, the Reserve Bank retains the power to exercise that discretion even after conceding that Custodia met all legal eligibility requirements.
This leaves a formidable obstacle for enterprises built on specialized state charters. Their proposed safeguards must successfully navigate the federal regulatory review process before they can attain the direct payment access Custodia pursued.
Correspondent Banking Remains the Alternative to Direct Access
What Is the Immediate Result for Custodia?
The existing denial of the master account remains in effect, and the Supreme Court review pursued via this petition has concluded. Custodia has failed to secure the court order it sought to compel the Kansas City Fed to issue an account.
For any state-chartered institution lacking its own master account, correspondent banking continues to serve as the default alternative. That approach preserves an intermediary standing between the financial entity and the Federal Reserve’s payment utilities.
?FAQ
01Who Represented Custodia in Its Supreme Court Petition?
Kannon Shanmugam filed Custodia’s July 2026 petition. It asked the Court to review whether regional Reserve Bank presidents could refuse master accounts to legally eligible nonmember banks.
02What Did the Kansas City Fed Initially Tell Custodia?
In January 2021, the Kansas City Fed confirmed Custodia’s legal eligibility and stated there were “no showstoppers.” That early response preceded the stricter review framework published in August 2022 and the eventual rejection.
03When Did Custodia Apply for Federal Reserve Membership?
Custodia submitted its membership application in August 2021. It was a separate request to the Board of Governors, following the master-account application made to the Kansas City Fed.
04What Happened to Custodia’s Administrative Procedure Act Claim?
The district court dismissed that claim for lack of a final agency action on March 29, 2024. In the same ruling, Judge Skavdahl granted summary judgment to the Kansas City Fed on the account-access dispute.
05Which Judges Supported Rehearing the Appeal?
Judges Hartz, Tymkovich and Eid voted to grant rehearing in March 2026. The full Tenth Circuit nevertheless denied the request, leaving Custodia to pursue Supreme Court review.
06Why Did a Judge Call Account Denial “Akin to a Death Sentence”?
Tymkovich used that phrase in his dissent from the March 2026 rehearing denial to emphasize the importance of master-account access. It was his assessment of the consequences of exclusion from those services.
07When Did the Supreme Court Consider Custodia’s Petition?
The case was distributed for the Court’s November 13, 2026, conference. The refusal to review it appeared on the November 16 order list.
This article is for information only and is not financial advice.



