November 16, 2026

Cardano Voters Reject $5M Copper Plan by More Than 140 to 1

Cardano voters decisively rejected Toto Finance's 22 million ADA treasury request to establish a physical copper reserve, with opposing votes outpacing support by over 140 to 1 amid fee and volatility concerns.

Cardano Voters Reject $5M Copper Plan by More Than 140 to 1

Delegated representatives ultimately defeated Toto Finance’s 22 million ADA treasury request when voting concluded on November 15, 2026, causing Cardano’s physical copper proposal to fail its funding vote. The initiative drew 2.86 billion ADA in voting power against it compared to just 20.02 million ADA in favor, permanently shelving the project to establish a physical copper reserve.

This outcome preserves the remaining treasury capacity. Voters had voiced apprehensions regarding fees, fund custody, and dual exposure to fluctuations in both ADA and copper prices. Toto’s plan had sought to allocate approximately $5 million toward purchasing and tokenizing warehouse copper.

Cardano Copper Proposal Loses by More Than 140 to 1

Opposing votes outnumbered supportive ones by a margin exceeding 140 to 1, while an additional 131 million ADA registered as a vote of no-confidence. Less than 1% of the total stake participating either for or against the measure actually backed it.

Furthermore, the Constitutional Committee withheld its endorsement: three members cast negative votes, and four abstained. Operating independently from the delegated representatives’ funding decision, the committee evaluates spending initiatives to ensure they align with Cardano’s constitution.

ADA Treasury Holders Object to Fees and Dual Price Exposure

DRep John MacPherson pointed out that the treasury would be exposed to the volatility of both copper and ADA. While generally favoring real-world assets on the network, MacPherson noted that this particular proposal was “more honest about its risks than most,” as highlighted by U.Today.

The Cardano Foundation had already voiced its opposition in October. Its objections centered on granting the recipient exclusive control over 22 million ADA for a highly concentrated commodity investment, alongside steep fees and inadequate safeguards.

According to CoinDesk’s review of its October analysis, copper prices would have needed to climb roughly 49% for the treasury to recover its initial ADA expenditure, assuming the dollar price of ADA remained flat. That steep recovery hurdle heavily influenced stakeholders reviewing the investment.

Under the terms, Toto could have accrued up to 3.36 million ADA—about 15% of the total request—through technology, management, and execution fees, alongside profit margins on storage and insurance invoices. Even so, founder Monty Metzger maintained that “Toto takes no profit from this proposal.”

What Toto Finance’s Copper Plan Included

Spearheaded by Metzger, Toto Finance formally submitted the application on October 15, 2026. The blueprint earmarked 14.72 million ADA to acquire COMEX-grade copper and planned to issue CuTT tokens backed directly by the stored metal.

The strategy involved buying the physical commodity, generating tokens, and eventually liquidating the copper to funnel proceeds back to the treasury. Because delegated voters and the foundation objected to the structural design of the investment, the rejection halts all intended purchases.

Other ADA Treasury Applicants Retain Spending Capacity

Cardano participants established a strict 500 million ADA withdrawal limit. As of October 16, 2026, 457.4 million ADA had already been allocated, leaving 42.6 million ADA in available capacity—meaning Toto’s request would have consumed approximately 52% of that remaining balance.

For stakeholders and alternative applicants, tracking active commitments against the cap remains vital. Toto retains the option to file a revised funding proposal, potentially altering its fee structure, asset controls, or risk safeguards to address voter grievances.

FAQ

01What approval threshold applies to Cardano treasury withdrawals?

Treasury withdrawals require yes votes from 67% of active voting stake. Toto’s request received less than 1% of the stake that voted for or against it.

02How much copper would each proposed CuTT token represent?

Toto proposed issuing one CuTT token for each pound of copper. The tokens would have been backed by the physical metal purchased under the reserve plan.

03Where would Toto Finance have stored the copper?

The proposal specified a warehouse near New Orleans. The planned purchase was COMEX-grade copper, with 14.72 million ADA allocated to buying the metal.

04When would the copper have been sold and the proceeds returned?

The proposed holding period was 18 to 24 months before the copper’s sale. Proceeds were due back to the Cardano treasury by month 36.

05How long does Cardano’s 500 million ADA treasury withdrawal cap run?

The cap runs through approximately July 2027. It limits treasury withdrawals to 500 million ADA over that period.

This article is for information only and is not financial advice.

Share

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *